| Platinum | Juniper & Oak Consignments |
| Gold | Yxefinds |
| Silver | Better Off Duds |
| Bronze | Style Encore |
| Top Pick | 33rd St Vintage & Artisan Market |
| Top Pick | Mostly Midz Vintage Clothing |
| Top Pick | Reclaim Maternity Baby Kids |
| Top Pick | The Edit |
| Top Pick | Underground Trend Consignment |
| Top Pick | Village Green Thrift Shop |