| Platinum | Yxefinds |
| Gold | Home Again Vintage & Retro |
| Silver | Back to Coffee Beans |
| Silver | Vintage Mall YXE |
| Bronze | Juniper & Oak Consignments |
| Top Pick | Joanne's Treasure Trove |
| Top Pick | Original Grandma Vintage |
| Top Pick | Past & Present Antique Shop |
| Top Pick | Penn's Antiques |